BENNY'S ICE CREAM
2933 NEW YORK 28, OLD FORGE, NY 13420
Last inspected Jun 12, 2026
Official source: New York State Department of Health (health.ny.gov) · All data sources
Failed. Did not meet health requirements at the latest inspection. Many failures are fixed and re-inspected within days — check the inspection date.
This inspection record doesn’t carry an official letter grade — some health departments never issue one, and others (like NYC) post it after a grace period — so CleanPlate derived the status from the reported violation data. If the department posts an official grade, it replaces this automatically.
Order for delivery
This establishment failed its most recent health inspection. Review the record below before ordering.
The record, in plain English
CleanPlate holds 12 inspections on record for BENNY'S ICE CREAM, spanning August 2009 to June 2026 — every one straight from New York State Department of Health.
It has held failed across its last two inspections.
The most recent inspection noted 2 violations, 1 of them a critical item — the kind tied directly to foodborne-illness risk.
Every sentence above is computed directly from the official record — CleanPlate adds no opinions. How our grading works →
Inspection history
Jun 12, 2026
✕2 violations
- Critical: Canned foods found in poor conditions (leakers, severe dents, rusty, swollen cans)
- In use food dispensing utensils improperly stored
Aug 12, 2025
✕1 violation
- Critical: Canned foods found in poor conditions (leakers, severe dents, rusty, swollen cans)
Aug 29, 2024
✓Jun 21, 2023
✓1 violation
- Wiping cloths dirty, not stored properly in sanitizing solutions
Sep 1, 2021
✓Aug 8, 2018
✓1 violation
- Effective measures not used to control entrance (rodent-, insect-proof contruction). Harborage areas available for rodents, insects and other vermin
Jun 22, 2017
✓1 violation
- Accurate thermometers not available or used to evaluate refrigerated or heated storage temperatures
Jul 27, 2016
✓2 violations
- Accurate thermometers not available or used to evaluate refrigerated or heated storage temperatures
- Handwashing facilities inaccessible, improperly located, dirty, in disrepair, improper fixtures, soap, and single service towels or hand drying devices missing
Aug 5, 2015
✓Jul 19, 2013
✓Jun 23, 2011
✓Aug 12, 2009
✕2 violations
- Handwashing facilities inaccessible, improperly located, dirty, in disrepair, improper fixtures, soap, and single service towels or hand drying devices missing
- Critical: Canned foods found in poor conditions (leakers, severe dents, rusty, swollen cans)
More in Herkimer
Source: New York State Department of Health (health.ny.gov). Data shown unmodified from the official government record. CleanPlate is an independent service, not affiliated with any government agency. See something wrong? Report a data issue.